Research Highlights: Precision Sensing Technologies for Improved Nitrogen Use Efficiency in Corn and Wheat Production SystemsResearch Highlights, Precision Sensing Solutions for Improved NUE in Corn and Wheat Production Systems

Cotton plant height collected by hand versus plant height measured using a sonar device.  Ninety three percent of the variation in plant height could be explained using this indirect method of measurement.


July 17, 2006

Wheat OFIT (On-farm INSEY trials) results, 2006

Table 1. Nitrogen fertilizer applied for Wheat OFIT 2006 across sites, OK. 

Trt

Preplant N lb ac-1

Topdress

lb ac-1

Topdress N Applied, lb ac-1

Lahoma

LCB

Perkins

1

0

0

0

0

0

2

0

Flat

45

45

45

3

0

Flat

90

90

90

4

45

Flat

45

45

45

5

45

0

0

0

0

6

90

0

0

0

0

7

0

NFOA-CV

53

55

26

8

45

NFOA-CV

22

20

16

9

0

NFOA-Flat

53

55

26

10

45

NFOA-Flat

22

20

16

11

0

0

0

0

0

12

0

RI-NFOA

36

28

19

13

45

RI-NFOA

11

12

11

 

 

 

 

Table 2. Grain Yield for Wheat OFIT 2006 across sites, OK.              

Trt

Preplant N

lb ac-1

Topdress

lb ac-1

Grain Yield, bu ac-1

Lahoma

LCB

Perkins

1

0

0

33

41

19

2

0

Flat (45)

44

46

21

3

0

Flat (90)

50

50

23

4

45

Flat (45)

53

47

21

5

45

0

45

48

21

6

90

0

51

48

24

7

0

NFOA-CV

46

51

21

8

45

NFOA-CV

49

52

21

9

0

NFOA-Flat

44

49

20

10

45

NFOA-Flat

51

45

22

11

0

0

29

44

16

12

0

RI-NFOA

39

50

23

13

45

RI-NFOA

50

46

26

 

 

 

 

Table 3. Profit earned for Wheat OFIT 2006 across sites, OK.

Trt

Preplant N

lb ac-1

Topdress

lb ac-1

Profit, $ ac-1

Lahoma

LCB

Perkins

1

0

0

150

184

87

2

0

Flat

178

190

76

3

0

Flat

190

189

67

4

45

Flat

203

176

57

5

45

0

185

199

76

6

90

0

194

178

72

7

0

NFOA-CV

187

208

83

8

45

NFOA-CV

196

207

68

9

0

NFOA-Flat

177

197

79

10

45

NFOA-Flat

203

175

72

11

0

0

131

197

73

12

0

RI-NFOA

162

213

97

13

45

RI-NFOA

204

184

93

Preplant N fertilizer price lb-1: $ 0.40
Topdress N fertilizer price lb-1: $0.40
Wheat grain price bu-1: $4.50

3 Point Trials 2006
Profit maximized in 2 of 3 trials using 0-N preplant and the variable N rate applicator (treatment 3). 

Table 1. Nitrogen use efficiency and N fertilizer applied for 2006 Wheat 3 PT Trial at Efaw, Hennessey and Chickasha, OK.

Trt

Preplant N, lb ac-1

Topdress N*

Total N Applied, lb ac-1

Nitrogen Use Efficiency, %

Efaw

Hennessey

Chickasha

Efaw

Hennessey

Chickasha

1

0

0

0

0

0

-

-

-

2

120

0

120

120

120

6

6

0

3

0

NFOA

23

54

32

38

0

11

4

45

NFOA

55

83

59

20

6

1

5

0

SBNRC

22

39

26

27

10

0

6

45

SBNRC

57

76

55

20

7

0

7

45

 

80

99

95

12

0

4

8

90

0

90

90

90

12

6

9

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

* UAN – 28% N

Table 2. Nitrogen fertilizer, grain yield and profit for 2006 Wheat 3 PT trial at Efaw, Hennessey and Chickasha, OK.

Trt

Preplant N, lb ac-1

Efaw

Hennessey

Chickasha

Topdress N, lb ac-1

Yield,

bu ac-1

Profit,

$ ac-1

Topdress N, lb ac-1

Yield,

bu ac-1

Profit,

$ ac-1

Topdress N, lb ac-1

Yield,

bu ac-1

Profit,

$ ac-1

1

0

0

34

152

0

33

147

0

30

135

2

120

0

39

126

0

37

120

0

29

81

3

0

23

40

170

54

32

121

32

32

133

4

45

10

42

165

38

36

130

14

30

113

5

0

22

38

162

39

35

144

26

30

123

6

45

12

42

164

31

36

133

10

29

106

7

45

35

41

151

54

31

102

50

33

110

8

90

0

41

149

0

37

129

0

 

36

125

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Preplant N price lb-1: $ 0.40
Topdress N price lb-1: $ 0.40
Wheat grain price bu-1: $4.50

 

Nitrogen Use Efficiency, Nitrogen Fertilizers, NUE, Nitrogen and the EnvironmentFebruary 22, 2006

The Sensor Based Nitrogen Calculator now has 15 functional algorithms for corn, wheat, canola, sorghum and bermudagrass.

Sensor Based Nitrogen Rate Calculator
 

October 5, 2005

Can corn "catch up" when N fertilization is delayed until V6, V10, or VT growth stages?  If no N is applied preplant, it is unlikely that you can produce near maximum yields when N is delayed until V10 growth stages or later.  Ideally, a minimum amount of N is required preplant, with added N applied at or before V10.  The highest NUE's were in general observed from mid-season N applications.  When N fertilization was delayed until VT, grain yields were significantly reduced.

Table 1.  Treatment, Grain Yield, Grain N uptake, and NUE, for Efaw, Oklahoma, 2005.

Treatment

Preplant N

Stage

Topdress N Applied

Total N

Applied

Grain Yield

Grain N uptake

NUE

 

kg ha -1

%

1

0

-

0

0

6187

4331

.

2

90

-

0

90

8181

5727

25

3

180

-

0

180

8546

5982

15

4

0

V6

90

90

7570

5299

17

5

0

V6

180

180

9049

6334

18

6

0

V10

90

90

7691

5384

19

7

0

V10

180

180

7970

5579

11

8

0

VT

90

90

8175

5722

25

9

0

VT

180

180

8433

5903

14

10

90

V6

90

180

9104

6373

18

11

90

V10

90

180

9144

6401

18

12

90

VT

90

180

9056

6339

18

13

45

V10

45

90

8543

5980

29

14

45

V6

45

90

8272

5790

26

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Table 2. Treatment, Grain Yield, Grain N uptake, and NUE, for Lack Carl Blackwell, Oklahoma, 2005.

Treatment

Preplant N

 

Topdress N Applied

Total N

Applied

Grain Yield

Grain N uptake

NUE

kg ha -1

%

1

0

-

0

0

8842

6190

.

2

90

-

0

90

12862

9003

50

3

180

-

0

180

13814

9670

31

4

0

V6

90

90

14210

9947

67

5

0

V6

180

180

13563

9494

29

6

0

V10

90

90

12852

8997

50

7

0

V10

180

180

13927

9749

32

8

0

VT

90

90

12571

8800

46

9

0

VT

180

180

11454

8018

16

10

90

V6

90

180

14228

9960

33

11

90

V10

90

180

14345

10042

34

12

90

VT

90

180

14502

10151

35

13

45

V10

45

90

13405

9383

57

14

45

V6

45

90

13683

9578

60

Table 3. Treatment, Grain Yield, Grain N uptake, and NUE, for Haskell, Oklahoma, 2005.

Treatment

Preplant N

 

Topdress N Applied

Total N

Applied

Grain Yield

Grain N uptake

NUE

kg ha -1

%

1

0

-

0

0

3029

2121

.

2

90

-

0

90

4562

3194

19

3

180

-

0

180

4720

3304

10

4

0

V6

90

90

3889

2722

11

5

0

V6

180

180

3279

2296

2

6

0

V10

90

90

3537

2476

6

7

0

V10

180

180

4168

2917

7

8

0

VT

90

90

3483

2438

6

9

0

VT

180

180

3401

2381

2

10

90

V6

90

180

4742

3319

11

11

90

V10

90

180

3730

2611

4

12

90

VT

90

180

3720

2604

4

13

45

V10

45

90

3973

2781

12

14

45

V6

45

90

4519

3164

18

 
July 13, 2005

When evaluating yield level as a function of nitrogen use efficiency in the long-term continuous winter wheat trials, we found that NUE increases with increasing yield level.  Furthermore, this relationship was more pronounced as annual fertilizer N rates increased.  The importance of this work is that it will allow us to adjust mid-season NUE's based on predicted yield levels that can be predicted from mid-season NDVI readings.

The same relationship observed between yield level and NUE was also observed for RI and NUE.  Thus, altering NUE as a function of predicted RI, or predicted yield level will be a next step toward improving the mid-season SBNRC.

June 13, 2005

Natural variability within corn (Zea mays L.) production systems is a common observance, but the resolution at which this variability occurs and methods for mid-season management fail to factor in the spatial difference among corn plants.  The objective of this study was to estimate final grain yield of each corn plant by collecting the normalized difference vegetative index (NDVI) sensor data using a GreenSeeker™ optical instrument and plant height at the 8 leaf growth stage (V8).  NDVI readings were collected every 1.2 cm in rows 15 to 30 m in length.  Knowing the exact location of each plant, average NDVI values were calculated using half the distance between it and its neighbors and computing the respective mean for each plant.  As NDVI values were collected, it was clear that differences in plants could be detected using an optical sensor.  Grain yield and height determined >66 days earlier at the V8 growth stage was then obtained for each plant and was used to find a relationship with NDVI.  Using NDVI alone at V8 was useful in predicting final grain yield, but by adding height at V8, grain yield prediction was significantly improved from an R2 of 0.27 to 0.51.



Figure 6.  Grain yield prediction equation using the EFAW, LCB, and Hennessey sites from 2004 with the index
developed from the plant competition factor, linear distance, and INSEY (Equation 5).
 

May 11, 2005 (copy from Growing Point Magazine, March 2005)
Growing Point Magazine, March 2005

 

May 4, 2005

Improving nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) with remote sensing devices is an emerging technology. This study characterized grain yield and biomass yield of corn (Zea mays L.) and evaluated the spatial variability of corn growth in terms of normalized difference vegetative index (NDVI). Four rows, 30 m in length from two locations over two years were randomly selected for this study. A GreenSeeker™ Handheld sensor was used to collect NDVI readings at all possible growth stages during the life cycle of corn. NDVI increased with progression of vegetative growth stages until V10, where a plateau was encountered, followed by a decline in NDVI after the VT growth stage. Coefficient of variation (CV) data from the NDVI readings of each row revealed two dominant peaks during the life cycle of corn, one between the V6 and V8 growth stages and the second during the late reproductive growth stages. The CV data illustrated that the greatest variation expressed by corn during the vegetative growth stages was between the V6 and V8 growth stages. The highest correlation of NDVI with corn grain yield was found at the V7 to V9 growth stages, while CV and plant spacing had the highest correlation from the V7 to V9 growth stages. The CV also had a high correlation with grain and biomass yields at all growth stages. As remote sensing technology progresses, results indicate that the V8 growth stage will be vitally important as a physiological stage to best recognize spatial variability for nutrient application in corn.

Coefficient of variation from NDVI readings determined from 4 separate rows, over growth stages ranging from V3 to VT, EFAW Experiment Station, 2003.

 

April 25, 2005

Farmer video discussing the benefits of the N Rich Strip Program implemented in Oklahoma.

Jerrel Powell and Tom Denker discuss the N Rich Strip Program
Click on Questions Below to See Video

Jerrel Powell, Farmer near Council Hill, OK

Question: How have you used GreenSeeker Technology?
Question: Why is Nitrogen Important?
Question: What would you like to tell producers in OK about GreenSeeker Technology?

Tom Denker, Farmer near Enid, OK
Question: What is the benefit of GreenSeeker Technology?
Question: What do you think about OSU working with private industry to make this type of technology available to producers?
Question: Would you like to add anything?

March 10, 2005

It is very difficult to establish relationships between NDVI values and corn grain yield unless readings can be taken by plant.  This is because the large differences in yield, are found at the by-plant resolution.  When NDVI readings were collected by plant, at the V8 growth stage, and then plotted with grain yield (determined 3 months later), you can see the definite trend in NDVI and yield over 16 m of row where each plant was sensed individually, and harvested by plant. This was from a corn field near Ames, IA, where the average over both transects exceed the 2003 state average.
 

February 28, 2005

To achieve genetic yield potential, stands must be optimum, plant spacing must be exact, seed must be planted at ideal and uniform depth, all nutrients must be non-limiting, soil types must be ideal for the cultivar, and moisture, temperature, and all other environmental factors must be ideal during the entire growing season. All plants must emerge within one day. All plants must set at least one ear of corn and the ear must completely fill. Under these conditions, the range of yield and standard deviation of yield should theoretically approach zero.

Consequently, the upper boundary of regression curves fitted for the data reported must approach zero at the genetic yield potential. Similarly, both the range and standard deviation of yield should be small near zero-yield to satisfy results reported by Taylor et al., (1999), and Dobermann et al., (2003).

Seed suppliers do not normally publish genetic yield potential data. However, the National Corn Growers Association Corn Yield Contest results (www.NCGA.com) can serve as a surrogate for these data. In order to achieve maximum yields, contest participants attempt to manage all factors under their control to minimize reduction in corn yield from the cultivars genetic yield potential. First place yields for all classes from 2002, 2003, and 2004 ranged from 19,000 to 22,000kg ha-1. One can infer that these yields approached the genetic yield potential of the corn cultivars, and where by-plant variability would be low.
Relationship between the standard deviation of corn grain yield and actual yield over sites

The standard deviation curve peaked near 13000 kg ha-1 and declined at higher yields. However, most of that decline occurred at yields greater than 15000 kg ha-1. Average field scale corn yields in all areas reported in this paper were much less than 15000 kg ha-1. Clearly, by-plant corn yield variability is large within the yield ranges achieved by producers, and that was delineated to in the by-state and country averages.

(See complete article on this topic)

 
February 1, 2005

The relationship between plant population and CV from GreenSeeker NDVI readings was evaluated over 7 site-years. From this evaluation, a critical CV of 20 was determined using a linear-plateau model. When CVs were greater than 20, the plant population was poor with < 100 plants/m2. The ability of the crop to respond to added N was evaluated using several response indices (RIHarvest, RINDVI, RINDVI-CV). It was found that RINDVI-CV (NDVI of the N-rich plot / (NDVI of the check * SqRt of check CV)) provided improved prediction of RIHarvest compared to the conventional RINDVI (NDVI of the N-rich plot/NDVI of the check). It is suggested that when this is implemented into the algorithm, variable rate applicators will apply less N over areas that have CVs greater than 20. The reduction in N applied reduces the expense of farmers and risk of N being lost to the environment.

Figure 1. Relationship between the CV of NDVI readings and winter wheat plant population (7 locations, 2003-2004, multiple seeding rates and 6 varieties).

The observation that CV reached a peak at Feekes 5 to 6 suggests that current timing of application may have to be changed in order to maximize the efficiency of the technology. As to application direction, it was beneficial to see that it does not matter what direction the sensors are traveling across the seed row and that the NDVI values will remain the same. This is extremely important in that the applicators do not have the need to follow any rigid guidelines for the equipment to perform properly.


Figure 2. Change in CV, from NDVI readings collected from three N treatments in winter wheat, over time at the EFAW Research Farm, Stillwater OK (2004).

 

January 25, 2005

Is "plant to plant" variability the same whether fixed distances are used between plants or using actual measured distances? Turns out that the expressed variability is actually greater when using fixed distances that do not accurately reflect computed yields based on the area occupied.
 Fixed Distances or Actual Distances?  Does it affect the expressed variability

Experiments documenting by-plant differences in corn grain yield show that variability increases as yield levels increase. This work shows that regardless of yield level, the average hybrid corn grain yield difference from one plant to the next exceeds 2740 kg/ha or 44 bu/ac in producer fields.

Nitrogen Use Efficiency, Nitrogen Fertilizers, NUE, Nitrogen and the Environment